More Than an Insurance Agency

Learn who we are, what we stand for, and the local team that's protected Indiana families and businesses for over four decades.

Built on Knowledge, Care, and Protection

Hatoway Insurance opened its doors in 1984 with a simple belief: insurance should be personal. We started by protecting our own friends, family, and neighbors across Indiana. Four decades later, that same commitment still guides everything we do.

Over the years, we've stood beside our clients through storms, fires, and accidents. We've seen firsthand how the right coverage can hold a family or business together in its hardest moments. That experience taught us that knowledge and care matter just as much as any policy.

Today, Hatoway serves communities from five local offices and holds licenses across six states. As an independent agency, we answer to you, not the carriers. We take the time to understand your life, then shop top companies to build protection that truly fits.

The Values That Guide Us

Everything we do comes back to three simple values that have shaped Hatoway from day one.

Decades of experience mean we know the coverage you need and the pitfalls to avoid. We guide you with clarity, not confusion.

We insure friends, family and neighbors, so we take the time to truly understand your life and protect what matters most to you.

The right coverage from the right carrier keeps your family, business, and assets secure, so you can face the future with confidence.

Are You Confident You're Actually Covered?

Too many families and businesses discover coverage gaps only when it's too late. Let our team review your policy and build protection that truly fits. It only takes a few minutes to get started.